Rome's transition from a republican system of government to an imperial regime comprised more than a century of civil upheaval and rapid institutional change. Yet the establishment of a ruling dynasty, centered around a single leader, came as a cultural and political shock to Rome's aristocracy, who had shared power in the previous political order. How did the imperial regime manage to establish itself and how did the Roman elites from the time of Julius Caesar to Nero make sense of it? In this compelling book, Matthew Roller reveals a "dialogical" process at work, in which writers and philosophers vigorously negotiated and contested the nature and scope of the emperor's authority, despite the consensus that he was the ultimate authority figure in Roman society.
Roller seeks evidence for this "thinking out" of the new order in a wide range of republican and imperial authors, with an emphasis on Lucan and Seneca the Younger. He shows how elites assessed the impact of the imperial system on traditional aristocratic ethics and examines how several longstanding authority relationships in Roman society--those of master to slave, father to son, and gift-creditor to gift-debtor--became competing models for how the emperor did or should relate to his aristocratic subjects. By revealing this ideological activity to be not merely reactive but also constitutive of the new order, Roller contributes to ongoing debates about the character of the Roman imperial system and about the "politics" of literature.
Review:
... Clearly written and augmented with a bibliography and two indexes, this book will appeal to informed general readers and scholars alike. (Choice)
... The book as a whole is excellent, and can be recommended both for the contribution of the overall argument and for the insight of the individual readings. . . . It should be read by everyone interested in the Principate, the literature of that period, ancient philosophy, ethics, social history, and political theory. I look forward to reading it again. Ellen O'Gorman(Bryn Mawr Classical Review)
Table of contents:
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ix
ABBREVIATIONS xi
INTRODUCTION 3
PART ONE: ETHICS AND IMPERIAL IDEOLOGY 15
CHAPTER ONE The Ethics of Civil War: Competing Communities in Lucan 17
1. Overview 17
2. Traditional Roman Ethical Discourse 20
3. The ''Assimilating'' Viewpoint 29
4. The ''Alienating'' Viewpoint 36
5. Ethics and Armies in Conflict 43
6. The Narrator 47
7. Lucan and Early Imperial Aristocratic Ideology 54
CHAPTER TWO Ethics for the Principate: Seneca, Stoicism, and Traditional Roman Morality 64
I. Overview 64
2. Stoicism's Two Regimes of Value 66
3. Where Does Moral Value Reside? Stoic and Traditional Ethics 70
4. Who Judges and How? Dilemmas of Internal and External Evaluation 77
5. The Problem of Exempla 88
6. Ethics in Julio-Claudian Society: Military Glory and Senecan virtus 97
7. Ethics in Julio-Claudian Society: Flattery and Stoicism 108
8. Conclusion 124
PART TWO: FIGURING THE EMPEROR 127
CHAPTER THREE The Emperor's Authority: Dining, Exchange, and Social Hierarchy 129
I. Overview 129
2. Giving a Dinner: The Convivium as Object of Exchange 135
3. Speech and Power: Amicable and Hostile Reciprocity in the Convivium 146
4. Dining with Rulers: The Construction o f Imperial Authority 154
5. Imperial Authority and Gift Giving 173
6. The Emperor as Gift-Debtor 193
7. Conclusion 210
CHAPTER FOUR Modeling the Emperor: The Master-Slave Relationship and Its Alternatives 213
1. Overview 213
2. Freedom and Slavery: A Social Metaphor in Political Discourse 214
3. Father or Master? Two Models for the Emperor in Julio-Claudian Literature 233
4. Competing Paradigms for the Early Principate 247
5. Social Inversion and Status Anxiety 264
6. Status Anxiety and Stoic Remedies 272
7. Conclusion 286
BIBLIOGRAPHY 289
INDEX 301
Roller seeks evidence for this "thinking out" of the new order in a wide range of republican and imperial authors, with an emphasis on Lucan and Seneca the Younger. He shows how elites assessed the impact of the imperial system on traditional aristocratic ethics and examines how several longstanding authority relationships in Roman society--those of master to slave, father to son, and gift-creditor to gift-debtor--became competing models for how the emperor did or should relate to his aristocratic subjects. By revealing this ideological activity to be not merely reactive but also constitutive of the new order, Roller contributes to ongoing debates about the character of the Roman imperial system and about the "politics" of literature.
Review:
... Clearly written and augmented with a bibliography and two indexes, this book will appeal to informed general readers and scholars alike. (Choice)
... The book as a whole is excellent, and can be recommended both for the contribution of the overall argument and for the insight of the individual readings. . . . It should be read by everyone interested in the Principate, the literature of that period, ancient philosophy, ethics, social history, and political theory. I look forward to reading it again. Ellen O'Gorman(Bryn Mawr Classical Review)
Table of contents:
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ix
ABBREVIATIONS xi
INTRODUCTION 3
PART ONE: ETHICS AND IMPERIAL IDEOLOGY 15
CHAPTER ONE The Ethics of Civil War: Competing Communities in Lucan 17
1. Overview 17
2. Traditional Roman Ethical Discourse 20
3. The ''Assimilating'' Viewpoint 29
4. The ''Alienating'' Viewpoint 36
5. Ethics and Armies in Conflict 43
6. The Narrator 47
7. Lucan and Early Imperial Aristocratic Ideology 54
CHAPTER TWO Ethics for the Principate: Seneca, Stoicism, and Traditional Roman Morality 64
I. Overview 64
2. Stoicism's Two Regimes of Value 66
3. Where Does Moral Value Reside? Stoic and Traditional Ethics 70
4. Who Judges and How? Dilemmas of Internal and External Evaluation 77
5. The Problem of Exempla 88
6. Ethics in Julio-Claudian Society: Military Glory and Senecan virtus 97
7. Ethics in Julio-Claudian Society: Flattery and Stoicism 108
8. Conclusion 124
PART TWO: FIGURING THE EMPEROR 127
CHAPTER THREE The Emperor's Authority: Dining, Exchange, and Social Hierarchy 129
I. Overview 129
2. Giving a Dinner: The Convivium as Object of Exchange 135
3. Speech and Power: Amicable and Hostile Reciprocity in the Convivium 146
4. Dining with Rulers: The Construction o f Imperial Authority 154
5. Imperial Authority and Gift Giving 173
6. The Emperor as Gift-Debtor 193
7. Conclusion 210
CHAPTER FOUR Modeling the Emperor: The Master-Slave Relationship and Its Alternatives 213
1. Overview 213
2. Freedom and Slavery: A Social Metaphor in Political Discourse 214
3. Father or Master? Two Models for the Emperor in Julio-Claudian Literature 233
4. Competing Paradigms for the Early Principate 247
5. Social Inversion and Status Anxiety 264
6. Status Anxiety and Stoic Remedies 272
7. Conclusion 286
BIBLIOGRAPHY 289
INDEX 301