Alfred Pendarves 'Pen' Reynolds (born 4 May 1892, date of death unknown) was an Australian rules footballer who played for Collingwood in the VFL during the 1910s. Wesley college graduate Pen Reynolds was mainly a follower but could also play as a defender and in attack. He appeared in a total of four VFL Grand Finals, winning the 1917 and 1919 premiership deciders. The 1919 Grand Final win was his last game in the league.