Urged by her lively roommate, Zoe, Cleo reluctantly attends her first-ever fraternity party. Typically a bookworm who prefers nights in the library, Cleo is anxious about venturing into the party scene, but Zoe’s insistence convinces her to give it a try. At the party, Cleo is overwhelmed by the loud music, chaotic atmosphere, and unfamiliar social dynamics. However, her nerves are somewhat eased when she unexpectedly encounters Liam Parker, the charismatic classmate with whom she shares a European History course—and a secret crush. What begins as a night of discomfort turns into a flirtatious and fun encounter as Liam and Cleo bond over a game of beer pong and shared conversations. However, the night takes a surprising turn when Cleo and Liam are challenged to a daring game of Truth or Dare. This sparks the central drama of the book, where Cleo’s tentative steps into college social life collide with unexpected emotions, including her growing connection with Liam.