In 'The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture', Alexander McCaul meticulously examines the teachings of the Talmud in comparison to the authority of Scripture, presenting a scholarly analysis of Jewish religious texts. McCaul's writing style is both thorough and insightful, delving into biblical interpretations and theological debates with clarity and precision. The book is a valuable resource for those interested in understanding the relationship between Jewish tradition and biblical truth, offering a critical examination of Talmudic teachings. McCaul's work is situated within the context of 19th-century religious scholarship, providing a historical perspective on the interactions between Judaism and Christianity during that period. His rigorous approach to textual analysis sets this book apart as a significant contribution to the study of comparative theology. Readers will appreciate McCaul's erudition and attention to detail, as well as his thoughtful reflections on theological controversies. 'The old paths' is highly recommended for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the connections between ancient religious texts and modern religious beliefs.